Critical Examination report by Wu and Schwarzchild
Columbia University Technical Report 173 concluded that some corrections which the authors neglected in their calculations were substantial enough to render their conclusion questionable.
Columbia University Technical Report 173 concluded that some corrections which the authors neglected in their calculations were substantial enough to render their conclusion questionable.
Rustad and Ruby acknowledged experimental errors in a post-deadline presentation at the 1958 winter meeting of the American Physical Society. No abstract was recorded but it was later described by Ruby as "mea culpa."
Attention to the problematic He6 recoil experiment came to a head in September 1957 at the Rehovoth Conference on Nuclear Structure, the first major nuclear conference convened in Israel. Wu, T.D. Lee, E. Konopinski, Harry Lipkin and Hans Frauenfelder were among those to weigh in.